Methodology
Where the score comes from, what it actually measures, and why it deserves no more trust than it has earned.
In short
- The verdict depends on assumptions: the weight of each feature and the thresholds. Change them in the weights panel and the same answers produce a different verdict.
- The crowd result is the opinion of people who chose to fill in the survey. It is not a measurement and not a poll of a representative sample.
Why “yet”?
The “yet” in the name is a warning, not a prediction. No country is immune: a political system can drift towards fascism step by step, and each step can look unremarkable on its own. Asking the question regularly is a way of noticing the drift.
The name does not claim that any entry on this site is fascist or is bound to become so. Whether the answer is “yes”, “almost” or “no” is exactly what the survey and the weights panel leave open.
The question makes sense for historical cases too, because some of them are still disputed. Two are not: Hitler’s Germany and Mussolini’s Italy are here as reference points. If your settings say those were not fascism, that tells you something about the settings.
Britt’s list and where it comes from
The survey is built on the 14 characteristics from Laurence W. Britt’s article “Fascism Anyone?”, published in Free Inquiry (vol. 23, no. 2, Spring 2003). Britt compared seven regimes – Hitler’s Germany, Mussolini’s Italy, Franco’s Spain, Salazar’s Portugal, Papadopoulos’s Greece, Pinochet’s Chile and Suharto’s Indonesia – and listed the traits he believed they shared.
The list became hugely popular online, often with a wrong byline: Britt is frequently presented as a political scientist with a doctorate. He was not an academic researcher, and his text is commentary, not a scholarly study.
Limitations of the list
- It was built from seven regimes, of which only Germany and Italy are generally accepted by historians as fascist. The other five are military or conservative-authoritarian dictatorships whose classification is disputed.
- It does not measure what many scholars consider the essence of fascism: a mass grassroots movement and a myth of national rebirth. As a result it distinguishes poorly between fascism and an ordinary military junta.
- It describes states in power. A movement or party outside government can only be rated on its programme and rhetoric.
- Several features (sexism, corruption, cronyism) appear under almost any unchecked power, so they say little about fascism as such.
- The features are not independent: media control, suppression of unions and rigged elections usually come together, so simple summation counts the same phenomenon several times.
How the score is calculated
Each feature is rated on a scale from 0 to 1 in steps of 0.1. “Don’t know” skips the feature and the remaining weights are renormalised.
The overall score is a weighted mean: the sum of (weight × answer) divided by the sum of weights. A core score is computed separately – the same mean over the features marked as core.
- FASCISM: score ≥ the fascism threshold (0.75 by default) and core ≥ the core minimum (0.80 by default).
- ALMOST FASCISM: score ≥ the “almost” threshold (0.55 by default).
- NOT FASCISM: otherwise.
The same function computes the score on the server and in the browser, so the weights panel shows exactly what the person you send the link to will see.
Why weights and a core
The default weights are the author’s decision, not a fact. Features that better separate fascism from other forms of authoritarian rule are weighted higher; those that accompany almost any unchecked power are weighted lower.
By default the core consists of three features: nationalism (1), disdain for human rights (2) and enemies and scapegoats as a unifying cause (3). Features 5 (sexism) and 13 (corruption) are found almost everywhere power goes unchecked, whereas features 1–3 do more to distinguish fascism from ordinary authoritarianism. The core requirement means a corrupt military dictatorship without a national ideology cannot receive the “fascism” verdict on secondary features alone.
If you disagree with these assumptions, change them. The settings are stored in the page address, so you can share a link with your own weights.
Crowd opinion is not a measurement
- The survey is completed by volunteers. They are not a representative sample of any population.
- Answers depend on knowledge, political sympathies and who happened to share the link. That is why we show the distribution, the median and the interquartile range instead of a single mean, alongside a breakdown by self-declared political position.
- Results appear only after a minimum number of responses. Sudden spikes in activity are flagged and excluded from results by default until reviewed.
- Safeguards (captcha, one response per device, rate limits) make manipulation harder but do not rule it out.
Other definitions of fascism
Britt’s list is only one of many approaches, and not the one historians value most. At least three others are worth knowing:
- Robert O. Paxton, The Anatomy of Fascism (2004) – fascism as a form of political behaviour: obsession with community decline, cults of unity and purity, a mass party working with traditional elites.
- Roger Griffin, The Nature of Fascism (1991) – fascism as “palingenetic ultranationalism” – nationalism centred on a myth of national rebirth.
- Umberto Eco, Ur-Fascism (The New York Review of Books, 1995) – 14 features of “eternal fascism”; a different list from Britt’s, though the two are often confused.